Quick answer: Match toys to how your dog plays. Gentle nibblers and plush lovers do well with soft toys and stuffed animals. Shredders need sturdier plush, rope toys and treat-filled puzzles that redirect the urge to destroy. Power chewers need durable, solid rubber or nylon toys sized larger than their mouth. Safe toys are too big to swallow, have no small parts and pass the thumbnail test: if you can't press a fingernail into it, it may be too hard for teeth. Rotate toys weekly, inspect them often and throw out anything broken.

The four chew styles

Watch your dog with a new toy for a few minutes. Which sounds most like them?

• The gentle nibbler. Mouths and licks toys, carries them around, rarely damages anything.
• The plush lover. Adores soft toys, cuddles and carries them, may squeak them a lot but doesn't destroy them quickly.
• The shredder. Loves the challenge of tearing seams and pulling out stuffing and squeakers.
• The power chewer. Bites down hard and keeps chewing until something breaks. Often large or strong-jawed breeds, but any dog can be one.

Many dogs mix styles, and puppies often go through a power chewer phase while teething. See our puppy teething guide.

Gentle nibblers and plush lovers

These dogs are the easiest to shop for. Soft toys, crinkle toys and squeakers bring them joy, and they often keep a favorite for years.

• Plush toys. Choose sizes too big to swallow, with no loose button eyes.
• Crinkle and squeak toys. Great for play and comfort.
• Soft fetch toys. Fabric balls and frisbees are gentle on mouths.
• Comfort toys. A favorite plush can help anxious dogs settle in a crate or at bedtime.
• Puzzle toys. Easy-level puzzles keep busy brains happy.

Even gentle dogs can swallow squeakers if a seam splits, so check toys weekly.

Shredders

Shredders aren't being naughty. Tearing and dissecting is a natural behavior, linked to how dogs once handled prey. The goal is to give them a safe outlet.

• Reinforced plush. Toys with double-stitched seams and tough fabric last longer.
• Stuffing-free toys. Flat plush toys with no stuffing remove the main hazard.
• Rope toys. Great for tugging and chewing, but supervise and throw out loose strands, which can be dangerous if swallowed.
• Shred-safe cardboard. Supervised cardboard boxes with treats inside can satisfy the urge to tear.
• Treat puzzles. Give the brain a job so the jaws don't have to do all the work.

Supervise shredders with new toys, and pick up stuffing and squeakers right away. Swallowed toy parts are a common cause of intestinal blockages.

Power chewers

Power chewers need toys built to take serious jaw pressure. Durability matters, but so does safety.

• Solid rubber toys. Tough, bouncy and often stuffable with food. Choose the extra-strong range in a larger size.
• Durable nylon chews. Long-lasting for strong chewers. Replace them when they get sharp edges or become small.
• Heavy-duty balls. Solid rubber balls sized well above mouth size.
• Stuffable chew toys. Freeze them with food for long-lasting enrichment.
• Size up. Choose a toy that's bigger than the label suggests if your dog is a strong chewer.

Avoid very hard items like antlers, real bones, hooves and hard plastic, which are common causes of broken teeth. Our dog bad breath guide explains how dental injuries happen.

If your power chewer breaks a toy in minutes, it's not the right toy, no matter what the label says.

Toy types every dog benefits from

Most dogs do best with a mix of toy types that meet different needs:

• Chew toys. For calm, satisfying chewing that relieves stress.
• Puzzle and treat toys. For mental enrichment. See brain games for dogs.
• Fetch toys. For exercise and bonding.
• Tug toys. For play with you, which builds confidence and impulse control when done with rules.
• Comfort toys. For settling and cuddling.
• Snuffle mats and lick mats. For calm sniffing and licking, great before bedtime or during storms.

Aim to have at least one toy from three or four of these categories in your rotation. Variety keeps your dog's body and brain busy, and it helps you discover which kinds of play your dog loves most. You might be surprised to find your gentle nibbler is secretly a puzzle genius.

Toy safety rules

Toys should be fun, not dangerous. Follow these rules for every dog:

• Right size. Too big to fit fully in your dog's mouth or throat.
• The thumbnail test. If you can't press a fingernail into a chew, it may be hard enough to break teeth.
• No small parts. Remove tags, bells and button eyes.
• Inspect weekly. Throw out toys that are torn, cracked or worn down.
• Supervise new toys. Especially with shredders and power chewers.
• Watch for string and fabric. Long strands from ropes and fabric can cause serious blockages if swallowed.
• Separate toys in multi-dog homes. If dogs guard toys, give them apart.

If your dog swallows a toy part and shows vomiting, lack of appetite or a painful belly, call your vet right away. Keep our dog first aid kit checklist handy.

Toy rotation: make toys exciting again

Dogs often lose interest in toys that are always lying around. Rotating toys keeps them feeling new and saves money.

Keep four or five toys out at a time and store the rest in a closet. Every week, swap a few. A toy your dog ignored last week can suddenly become the best thing ever. Make a small ritual of it, like a toy reveal on Sunday mornings, and watch your dog's excitement.

Toys for puppies and seniors

Puppies need soft rubber toys for teething, freezable chews to soothe gums and lots of supervision. Avoid hard adult chews until adult teeth are in.

Senior dogs may have sensitive teeth or weaker jaws. Softer rubber, plush toys and gentle puzzles suit them well. Lick mats and snuffle mats give them calm enrichment without strain. See caring for a senior dog.

Play with your dog, not just toys

Toys are most fun when you join in. Interactive play builds your bond and burns energy faster than solo chewing.

Try short games of tug with a clear start and stop cue, fetch with a soft toy, hide-and-seek with a favorite plush or find-it games with treat toys. End games while your dog still wants more, and put special toys away afterward so they stay exciting. Our is my dog happy quiz shows how play supports happiness.

Dog toy myths

A few common beliefs:

• Tough dogs need the hardest chews. Very hard chews often break teeth. Durable rubber is usually safer.
• Any toy labeled indestructible is safe. No toy is truly indestructible. Supervise and inspect.
• More toys mean a happier dog. A few rotated toys and your playtime matter more.
• Destroying toys means a dog is bad. It's normal play. Offer the right outlets.

Easy DIY toys

You don't need to spend a lot. Knot an old T-shirt into a tug toy, hide treats in a muffin tin under tennis balls, or roll kibble inside a towel for a snuffle game. Always supervise homemade toys and throw them out once they start to fall apart. Cardboard boxes stuffed with paper and a few treats make a fun, supervised shredding game for dogs who love to tear.

Toy ideas by breed group

Breed history often shapes what dogs love to do with toys.

• Retrievers and spaniels. Love carrying and fetching. Soft fetch toys, floating toys and plush carry toys.
• Terriers. Bred to dig and catch. Tug toys, squeakers, flirt poles and digging boxes.
• Herding breeds. Love chasing and problem solving. Herding balls and puzzle feeders.
• Scent hounds. Live through their noses. Snuffle mats and hide-and-seek treat games.
• Bully breeds. Often strong chewers. Durable rubber toys and sturdy tug ropes with supervision.
• Toy breeds. Small, soft toys sized for tiny mouths, plus gentle puzzles.
• Sighthounds. Love a chase. Lure-style toys and soft balls for short sprints.

Every dog is an individual, so treat these as starting points and follow your dog's lead.

Cleaning and storing toys

Toys collect drool, dirt and bacteria. Wash plush toys in the washing machine on a gentle cycle every week or two, and air dry them fully. Rubber and nylon toys can go in the top rack of the dishwasher or be scrubbed with warm, soapy water.

Store rotation toys in a lidded basket or bin out of reach so they stay special. A low open basket for everyday toys lets your dog choose their favorite. Many dogs love learning a tidy up cue, dropping toys back into the basket for a treat, which is a fun trick to show off to guests.

Toys that help anxious or bored dogs

The right toy can be a calming tool as well as a fun one. Chewing and licking release tension, which is why a stuffed, frozen rubber toy or a lick mat is often recommended for dogs who struggle with alone time, thunderstorms or fireworks.

Offer these calming toys only at specific times, like when you leave the house or during a storm, so they become a signal that everything is okay. Pair them with a cozy blanket in a quiet spot. For long-lasting enrichment, fill a rubber toy with your dog's kibble mixed with a little plain yogurt or pumpkin, then freeze it overnight.

If your dog still panics when alone, toys alone won't solve it. Our separation anxiety guide and thunderstorm anxiety guide walk through step-by-step plans.

Cheat sheet

Before you buy:

• Know your dog's chew style.
• Choose toys bigger than their mouth.
• Use the thumbnail test for hard chews.
• Mix chew, puzzle, fetch and comfort toys.
• Inspect weekly and throw out broken toys.
• Rotate toys to keep them exciting.

• Know the chew style. Nibbler, plush lover, shredder or power chewer.
• Size up. Bigger than the mouth.
• Thumbnail test. Too hard can break teeth.
• Mix toy types. Chew, puzzle, fetch, comfort.
• Inspect and rotate. Safer and more exciting.

Image: Product photo

Shop now

Shop this article

What are the best toys for aggressive chewers?

Durable solid rubber or nylon toys sized larger than your dog's mouth, used with supervision.

Are rope toys safe for dogs?

With supervision. Throw them out when strands come loose, since swallowed fibers can cause blockages.

Are antlers and bones safe chews?

They're common causes of broken teeth. Many vets suggest softer alternatives.

How many toys should a dog have?

A handful out at a time, rotated weekly, works well for most dogs.

Why does my dog destroy toys?

Shredding is a natural behavior. Offer sturdier toys and puzzle feeders to redirect it.

What toys are best for puppies?

Soft rubber teething toys, freezable chews and supervised plush toys.

How often should I replace dog toys?

Whenever they're torn, cracked, worn small or have loose parts.

Are squeaky toys safe?

Yes, with supervision. Remove the squeaker if the toy splits.

What is the thumbnail test?

If you can't press a fingernail into a chew, it may be too hard for your dog's teeth.

Do dogs get bored of toys?

Yes. Rotating toys and playing together keeps them interesting.